We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.
35 Seriously Scary Costumes to Haunt Your Halloween
These creepy masks and horrifying outfits are ideal for singles, couples or whoever loves a good fright.
Some people try to look cute, cool or clever when it's time to dress up in a costume, and that's fine. But when it comes to great Halloween costumes, our hats are off to whoever can dress up and send a tingle running down our spines. Sometimes, even though we can see the face paint, the creases in the masks and the fake nails used to make the fingers so craggy and pointy, these costumes still manage to get under our skin — which is exactly what you're supposed to do on Halloween.
These are the best scary costumes to buy in 2023. A few of them come from our favorite pop-culture ghouls and haunts and have movies or TV series that do a lot of the scary work for you. Others are just unsettling to look at, with bulging eyes and wrinkly features that just look so spooky in the dark of night. There are a few that can be easily DIYed or put together with just a mask and some items you may already have in your closet.
And don't worry, we have horrifying outfits that are ideal for singles, couples or whoever loves a good fright. But whichever one you choose, watch out for nightmares!
Looking for more great costume inspiration? Check out these Good Housekeeping guides:
The movie Terrifier and its sequel are verifiable word-of-mouth hits, but you'll be sure to terrify people in this costume even if no one had ever heard of Art the Clown — its vibe is just too creepy. This costume comes with the clown outfit and the teeth, so you have to do your own scary makeup.
If you're looking to turn your dress-up event into a date night, try the coordinating zombie patient and zombie nurse couples' costume. For a more youthful twist on the idea, you can also try the zombie football player and zombie cheerleader costumes, but the nurse is scarier in our opinion.
Sometimes, it's what you don't see that is the scariest. This costume comes with a black full-body suit and light-up glasses, so you can be the glowing eyes in the night.
Why is this jack o'lantern smiling? For no good reason, we can tell you that! This costume comes with the tunic, collar, belt and mask — you just need to add the wig.
No one would want to be trapped overnight with this alive animatronic demon! This is the titular Freddy Fazbear, but there are also kids' costumes for Foxy, Chica and Bonnie, all of whom are equally creepy.
The best part about this costume is getting to come up with the ghost bride's backstory. Was she jilted on her wedding day? Expired before she could walk down the aisle? You get to decide. This costume comes with the dress and veil.
Step right up for the scariest show on Earth! This costume comes with the mask, jacket, vest, tie and top hat, but you have to bring your own sense of showmanship. You can also get a skeleton ringmistress costume to go with it if you want to make it a double act.
No one will be able to look you in the (milky white) eyes when you're wearing this flexible demon mask. (Be warned, though: Amazon reviewers say it can be hard to see through.)
There are plenty of clowns on this list, and each one earns its place in a different way. This costume is inflatable, and its outsize proportions just serve to make it all the more unsettling.
The princesses may be the fairest ones of all, but Maleficent cuts the most striking figure, especially with those horns. The costume comes with the shawl and the horns, all you need is a black dress, black lipstick and a scowl.
This costume pulls off a neat trick: Since the shoulders and neck are fake, and worn over your own head, it makes it look like you have your own face in your hands. Who needs a headless horseman when you have this?
You don't have to have seen The Purge to find these light-up masks unsettling. They come in several colors, but be warned: The laws do still apply while you're wearing them.
The so-called viral "Momo Challenge" almost feels retro by now, but that face is still so disturbing. Really, this mask is all you need to win Halloween.
Everyone definitely wants to keep this 17th-century plague doctor away. The mask isn't included with the outfit, but that just means you can choose if you want a black one or a white one.
With a new movie in the Nun franchise coming out this year, it might be time to revive this old haunt. The fright is all in the mask for this Conjuring universe-inspired outfit. Bonus: The unisex robe itself is comfy, too.
This killer clown costume is perfect for high school and middle school students looking for something a little freaky. It comes with a jumpsuit, collar and full-head mask.
Scare everyone as the murderous Michael Myers from the Halloween movies — a mask that can truly never be forgotten. It's a full, over-the-head mask, so you'll be completely disguised.
Straight from the halls of the Upside-Down version of Creel House, this Vecna mask is ready to haunt your nightmares! Just hope that no one has "Running Up That Hill" cued up on their walkman.
Marisa (she/her) has covered all things parenting, from the postpartum period through the empty nest, for Good Housekeeping since 2018; she previously wrote about parents and families at Parents and Working Mother. She lives with her husband and daughter in Brooklyn, where she can be found dominating the audio round at her local bar trivia night or tweeting about movies.